Holistic Select Cat Food Review

The Holistic Select company was founded about 10 years ago and it has rapidly risen through the ranks as one of the leading suppliers of holistic pet foods. Holistic Select has made a commitment to high-quality, natural nutrition that is easy to digest and full of natural flavor. This company believes that good health starts with healthy digestion which is why all of their recipes are made with the Unique digestive Health Support System which includes prebiotics, probiotics, natural fibers, digestive enzymes, and digestive botanicals. This system is supplemented with wholesome fruits and veggies, high-quality proteins, whole grains, and omega fatty acids. Holistic Select offers a money-back guarantee on their products just to make sure you and your cat both love them.

Chewy Online Pet Supplies


Why Buy from Chewy?

Hint: They sent a card...

Read Story

Where is Holistic Select Cat Food Made?

The Holistic Select brand of cat food is produced and manufactured by WellPet, LLC. This company was founded in 1926 as the Old Mother Hubbard brand of natural dog snacks. The company changed hands several times over the next few decades until the Holistic Select brand was released in 2000. In 2008, the brand was sold to the Berwind Corporation, the parent company for WellPet, LLC. All of WellPet’s products are made in the United States in company-owned facilities.

Are There Any Recalls for Holistic Select Cat Food in 2020?

Holistic Select is dedicated to quality not only in the formulation of their recipes, but in their manufacture as well. This company employs the strictest standards for safety and quality in the production of their pet foods, using only the highest quality ingredients available. Holistic Select follows a quality assurance program that exceeds FDA requirements and AAFCO standards to make sure that Holistic Select pet foods are nothing but the best. All of this being true, you should not be surprised to learn that Holistic Select has not been affected by any product recalls to date.

Holistic Select Cat Food Coupons 2020

Chewy Online Pet Supplies


30% Off + Free Shipping

on Holistic Select Cat Food

Shop Now

What Kind of Products Does Holistic Select Offer?

When it comes to their cat food products, Holistic Select offers a more limited variety than they do for dog foods. Holistic Select has a total of four dry food recipes and seven wet food recipes. All of the canned food options are grain-free while only one of the four dry food recipes is. Every recipe, however, is complete and balanced and made with high-quality ingredients.

Holistic Select Air-Dried Cat Food Products

Holistic Select may only offer four dry cat food products, but each and every one of them offers excellent nutritional quality. All four recipes start with a high-quality meat meal as the primary source of protein, ensuring that every recipe is protein-rich and loaded with natural flavor. Holistic Select uses digestible carbohydrates like potatoes, peas, and ground brown rice for carbohydrate and dietary fiber, with chicken fat and fish oils for healthy fat content. Here is a list of Holistic Select dry cat food recipes:

  • Adult & Kitten Health Chicken Meal Recipe
  • Adult Health Anchovy & Sardine & Salmon Meals Recipe
  • Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe
  • Grain-Free Indoor Health/Weight Control Turkey, Chicken & Herring Meals Recipe

Holistic Select Wet Cat Food Products

Compared to their dry food offerings, Holistic Select offers a wider variety of wet foods. With seven options to choose from, customers can select from poultry- or fish-based recipes supplemented with grain-free, digestible carbohydrates like flaxseed, apple, and pumpkin. All of Holistic Select’s wet foods are free from corn, wheat, and soy ingredients as well as artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives. Here is a list of Holistic Select wet cat food recipes:

  • Grain-Free Chicken Liver & Lamb Paté
  • Grain-Free Ocean Fish & Tuna Paté
  • Grain-Free Salmon & Shrimp Paté
  • Grain-Free Chicken Paté
  • Grain-Free Turkey Paté
  • Grain-Free Turkey & Salmon Paté
  • Grain-Free Chicken, Whitefish & Herring Paté

Dry Cat Food Recipe Review: Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe Dry Food

This Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal recipe is protein-rich and full of natural duck flavor. With duck meal as the main ingredient, this recipe is a great choice for cats that suffer from food allergies and sensitivities because duck is a novel protein for most cats. It also helps that this recipe is made with the unique Digestive Health Support System that includes prebiotics, probiotics, natural fibers, digestive enzymes, and digestive botanicals. This recipe also includes omega-3 fatty acids to support your cat’s healthy skin and coat plus antioxidant-rich cranberries for immune support.

As you already know, the first ingredient in this Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal recipe is duck meal. Duck meal is simply fresh duck that has been cooked to a moisture level around 10% – this makes it a much more highly concentrated source of protein than fresh duck. The duck meal is supplemented by chicken meal and dried egg product which contribute to a crude protein content of 32%. It is important to note, however, that there are some plant proteins at work in this recipe as well. Dried alfalfa meal, for example, is loaded with plant protein and quinoa contains some as well. These ingredients appear further down the list, however, so they are unlikely to make any significant contribution to the total protein content of this formula.

After the duck meal comes ground brown rice – the main source of carbohydrate in this recipe and a highly digestible source at that. Ground rice is easy for most cats to digest but keep in mind that it is a grain so some cats with grain allergies or sensitivities may not react well to this Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal recipe. The brown rice is supplemented by oatmeal and flaxseed as well as fresh fruits and vegetables plus quinoa. In addition to being supplementary sources of dietary fiber, the fresh fruits and veggies also act as natural sources for key nutrients. Natural sources are always more biologically valuable for cats than synthetic supplements.

The remaining ingredients in this Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal recipe consist primarily of fats, flavors, and supplements. The main source of fat in this recipe is chicken fat – a highly nutritious ingredient and a concentrated source of energy. It is supplemented by flaxseed which helps to ensure a balance of omega fatty acids for healthy skin and coat. In terms of supplements, this recipe contains vitamin supplements, chelated minerals, and dried fermentation products. Chelated minerals are minerals that have been chemically bound to protein molecules which makes them easier for your cat’s body to digest and absorb. Dried fermentation products act as probiotics to help support your cat’s healthy and regular digestion.

This Holistic Select recipe has a guaranteed analysis as follows:

  • Crude Protein (Min) – 32%
  • Crude Fat (Min) – 20%
  • Crude Fiber (Max) – 2.8%
  • Moisture (Max) – 10%
  • Taurine (Min) – 0.17%
  • Calcium (Min) – 1.2%
  • Phosphorus (Min) – 0.9%
  • Vitamin A (Min) – 22,000 IU/kg
  • Vitamin E (Min) – 75 IU/kg
  • Omega-6 Fatty Acids (Min) – 3.6%
  • Omega-3 Fatty Acids (Min) – 0.52%
  • Calorie Content – 4,017 kcal/kg, 490 calories/cup

This Holistic Select recipe is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by AAFCO Cat Food Nutrient Profiles for maintenance. To feed your cat this recipe, offer cats weighing 6 to 8 pounds 1/3 to ½ cup daily, ideally dividing it into two meals. For cats weighing 8 to 10 pounds, offer ½ to 2/3 cups daily divided into two meals. For adult cats, follow the feeding recommendations for several weeks while keeping an eye on your cat’s bodyweight and condition. If your cat appears to be gaining an unhealthy amount of weight, you may need to scale back his daily portion a little bit. For cats that lose weight or become lethargic, consider increasing the daily portion. This product should be fed at room temperature and any uneaten portion should be stored in a cool, dry place.

Holistic Select Dry Cat Food Recipe Rating: 4.5/5 stars

Overall, this Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal recipe offers high-quality nutrition through the use of premium, natural ingredients. This recipe starts off strong with highly concentrated duck meal as the main ingredient and primary source of protein – it is also supplemented by chicken meal and dried egg. Ground brown rice is a valuable addition to this recipe and a digestible carbohydrate, though some cats may not react well to this ingredient. This recipe contains several supplementary sources of digestible carbohydrate and dietary fiber which also act as natural sources for key nutrients. All in all, this recipe contains plenty of healthy ingredients, beneficial supplements, and nothing that is overtly harmful for cats. Your cat would be lucky to enjoy this product.

Wet Cat Food Recipe Review: Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté Wet Food

This Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe is formulated for cats in all life stages from kitten to senior. This formula is made with high-quality proteins that not only help to support your cat’s lean muscle mass, but also contribute plenty of healthy fats and natural flavor. Like all of Holistic Select’s products, this formula contains with the unique Digestive Health Support System that includes prebiotics, probiotics, natural fibers, digestive enzymes, and digestive botanicals. It is also free from corn, wheat, and soy ingredients as well as artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Simply put, this recipe contains all of the healthy nutrients your cat needs with nothing he doesn’t.

The first ingredient in this Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe is chicken and it is followed by chicken liver. Both of these are protein-rich ingredients, though the chicken liver is more valuable as a source of healthy fat and key nutrients. This recipe also contains supplementary proteins in the form of fresh turkey and a small amount of plant protein from the flaxseed. These proteins work together with the chicken broth to create a moist, flavorful product without the need for artificial flavors. Overall, this recipe contains 10% crude protein which translates to a dry matter value of 45%.

After the proteins and broth comes ground flaxseed. Ground flaxseed is a multipurpose ingredient – not only does it provide dietary fiber, but it also contains healthy fats and a small percentage of plant protein. Flaxseed works with the primary proteins in this recipe to provide a balance of omega fatty acids and a total fat content of 5%. This translates to a dry matter value of 22% which is well within the appropriate range for cats. Cats needs plenty of healthy fats in their diet because fats are the most highly concentrated source of energy available and they also help to maintain the health and vitality of your cat’s skin and coat.

The remaining ingredients in this Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe consist primarily of fiber supplements, thickeners, vitamins, and minerals. As far as fiber supplements go, this recipe contains apple powder, cranberry powder, pumpkin powder, chicory root extract, blueberry powder, papaya powder, and pomegranate powder. Many of these act as prebiotic fibers to support your cat’s digestion while also contributing key vitamins. Several of the mineral supplements included in this recipe are chelated which helps to make them easier for your cat’s body to digest and absorb. In terms of thickeners, this recipe uses both cassia gum and xanthan gum – neither of these is considered a low-quality or dangerous ingredient.

This Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe has a guaranteed analysis as follows:

  • Crude Protein (Min) – 10%
  • Crude Fat (Min) – 5%
  • Crude Fiber (Max) – 1.0%
  • Moisture (Max) – 78%
  • Taurine (Min) – 0.1%
  • Calorie Content – 1,290 kcal/kg, 110 calories per 3-ounce can

This Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by AAFCO Cat Food Nutrient Profiles for all life stages. To feed your cat this recipe, offer 2 3-ounce cans per 6 to 8 pounds of bodyweight per day, ideally dividing it into two meals. Growing kittens may require up to twice this amount and pregnant or lactating female cats may need two to four times this amount. For adult cats, follow the feeding recommendations for several weeks while keeping an eye on your cat’s bodyweight and condition. If your cat appears to be gaining an unhealthy amount of weight, you may need to scale back his daily portion a little bit. For cats that lose weight or become lethargic, consider increasing the daily portion. This product should be fed at room temperature and any uneaten portion should be refrigerated.

Holistic Select Canned Cat Food Recipe Rating: 4/5 stars

Overall, this Holistic Select Grain-Free Chicken Paté recipe is a high-quality source of balanced nutrition for cats in all life stages. This recipe starts off strong with fresh chicken and chicken liver as the top two ingredients, followed by chicken broth for moisture and natural flavor. For carbohydrates and fiber, this recipe relies on ground flaxseed as well as a number of fruit and berry powders. This recipe is well within the recommended range for protein and fat, though it is nearing the upper limit for fiber. This recipe could also be improved by the addition of probiotics to balance out all of the prebiotic fibers.

Final Thoughts

As a whole, the Holistic Select brand of pet food offers excellent quality nutrition for cats in all life stages. This brand may not offer as many options as other pet food brands, but all of the formulas they do provide are made with high-quality proteins, digestible carbohydrates, and healthy fats. Holistic Select is also particularly concerned about healthy digestion in cats as a means of improving and maintaining whole-body health. That is why they include their unique Digestive Health Support System that includes prebiotics, probiotics, natural fibers, digestive enzymes, and digestive botanicals in every recipe. If you are looking for a cat food brand that offers complete and balanced nutrition using all of the nutrients your cat needs and nothing he doesn’t, look no further than Holistic Select.

Kate Barrington

Kate Barrington is a freelance writer specializing in the subject of pet health and wellness. An avid dog lover and adoring owner of three cats, Kate has a great deal of experience writing about all kinds of pets and all aspects of pet care. Her work has been featured on a number of pet websites and she is a regular columnist for Tropical Fish Hobbyist Magazine.

View all posts

5 comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • I keep looking for the perfect food for my 3 cats.
    I was all set to try the Holistic Select turkey. When reading the reviews, one review told of being happy with the food. Then she opened 1 can and it had an unpleasant odor. It had bile in it. Several other cans also had it too. This was upsetting. Has this been a problem before?

    Thank you so much.

    • I use blue buffalo wet only. Still, I always keep searching. When I read the latest scientific ( supposedly) reviews, the best ones they say I have seen people posting images with maggots or other things! It’s really difficult! What I read is the best in my oppinion is horrid. Almost all have had recalls. I won’t use grains, gluten, by products or bpa cans or fish! Too much toxic junk in even human fish these days. Tuna cans even say pregnant women shouldn’t eat it. It’s really hard. And I’m one of those people who lives for her Cats! Dry is deadlt. Causes crystals and stones.

  • My cats have eaten Holistic Select for years. They are all in excellent health, and people always remark how shiny and soft their coats are. I have never had a bad can. They only eat the Turkey and Salmon and the Chicken flavors. I order it by the case through Amazon. My oldest of four cats is 19.

We Send Recall Notices, Product Reviews, and Special Deals Straight To Your Inbox. No Kitten.

Sign up and join thousands of cat lovers in receiving news, coupons and cute kitties via email.

You're in! As a thank you enjoy 30% Off your next purchase at Chewy.com.

Save 30% at Chewy.com

{"popup_ID":2939,"when_popup_appear":"exit","delay":"","x_second":"","x_scroll":"","disappear":"","exptime":"","hideclsbtn":"","clsonesc":"1"}